Welcome Back To Side Hustle Weekly!

If you haven’t already please take our survey this helps us curate the best side hustles and business ideas to best fit your needs.

I’m excited to share with you another great side hustle you can start today! Today we will be discussing how you can start a themed mystery box subscription service

$10k Per Month From Mystery Boxes

Mystery box subscription businesses are booming, offering customers the excitement of receiving curated surprises every month. Whether it’s Pokémon collectibles, gaming merchandise, tech gadgets, or themed lifestyle items, the possibilities are endless. With the right strategy, you can turn this trend into a lucrative business. This guide will walk you through the steps to start and run a successful mystery box subscription business, from choosing a niche to scaling your income.

Step-by-Step Guide to Starting a Mystery Box Subscription Business

Step 1: Choose Your Niche

The first step is to define your target audience and the theme of your mystery box. Your niche should align with your passions or expertise while appealing to a specific group of customers.

• Popular Niche Ideas:

  • Pop Culture: Pokémon, anime, video games, or superhero-themed boxes.

  • Tech Gadgets: Monthly gadgets, tools, or accessories for tech enthusiasts.

  • Hobbies: Craft supplies, cooking ingredients, or workout gear.

  • Luxury Items: High-end beauty products, gourmet snacks, or limited-edition collectibles.

Narrowing your focus helps attract loyal subscribers and sets you apart in a crowded market.

Step 2: Plan Your Box Contents

A successful mystery box balances surprise and value. Research items your audience will find exciting while staying within your budget.

• Tips for Planning:

  • Include a mix of exclusive, high-value, and fun items.

  • Offer 3-5 items per box to provide variety without overwhelming subscribers.

  • Negotiate bulk discounts with suppliers or wholesalers.

If possible, include at least one unique item per box (e.g., limited-edition merchandise or custom designs) to keep subscribers engaged.

Step 3: Calculate Pricing and Profit Margins

Set your subscription price based on the cost of goods, shipping, and your desired profit margin.

• Pricing Example:

  • Cost of items per box: $20

  • Packaging and shipping: $5

  • Total cost: $25

  • Subscription price: $40

  • Profit margin: $15 per box (~37.5%)

Offer tiered pricing options, such as a basic box and a premium box, to appeal to different budgets.

Step 4: Build a Website and Subscription Platform

Your website is the foundation of your business, where customers subscribe, learn about your theme, and manage their accounts.

• Key Features for Your Website:

  • A professional design that reflects your brand.

  • Easy-to-use subscription sign-up and management.

  • A blog or FAQ page to address common questions.

• Recommended Platforms:

  • Shopify with Bold Subscriptions: Easy to set up and manage.

  • WooCommerce: A WordPress plugin ideal for more customization.

  • Cratejoy: Specifically designed for subscription box businesses.

Investing in a quality platform ensures smooth customer experiences and recurring revenue.

Step 5: Source Products and Packaging

Find reliable suppliers for your box contents and high-quality packaging materials.

• Where to Source Products:

  • Wholesalers like Faire, Alibaba, or Doba.

  • Niche-specific brands willing to collaborate for exposure.

  • Local artisans or small businesses for unique items.

• Packaging Tips:

  • Use sturdy, branded boxes that make a great first impression.

  • Include branded tissue paper, stickers, or thank-you notes for a personal touch.

Packaging is part of the experience, so make it visually appealing and memorable.

Step 6: Market Your Mystery Box

Effective marketing is essential to attract and retain subscribers. Use a mix of organic and paid strategies to build awareness.

• Organic Strategies:

  • Create engaging content on Instagram, TikTok, or YouTube showcasing box unboxings.

  • Build an email list with exclusive offers or early bird pricing.

  • Partner with influencers in your niche for reviews and promotions.

• Paid Strategies:

  • Run targeted ads on Facebook or Google.

  • Use retargeting ads to convert website visitors into subscribers.

Unboxings and testimonials are particularly effective for building excitement and trust.

Step 7: Launch and Scale

Once you have your initial subscribers, focus on retention and growth.

• Retention Strategies:

  • Offer loyalty rewards for long-term subscribers.

  • Regularly solicit feedback to improve your box.

  • Add personalization options (e.g., choose a specific theme or item).

• Scaling Ideas:

  • Launch new themes or box tiers.

  • Introduce limited-edition seasonal boxes.

  • Expand your market to include international shipping.

Scaling allows you to maximize profits and cater to a broader audience.

Potential Monthly Earnings

Your income depends on the number of subscribers, pricing, and retention rates. Here’s an estimate:

• Starter Phase: 100 subscribers at $40/month = $4,000/month.

• Growth Phase: 500 subscribers at $50/month = $25,000/month.

• Established Business: 1,000 subscribers at $60/month = $60,000/month.

By increasing your subscriber base and introducing premium tiers, earnings can grow exponentially.

Pros and Cons of a Mystery Box Subscription Business

Pros:

• Recurring Revenue: Monthly subscriptions provide steady income.

• Scalability: Easy to grow by adding subscribers or themes.

• Creative Freedom: Curate boxes that reflect your interests.

• Loyal Community: Subscribers often become long-term customers.

Cons:

• Initial Investment: Costs for inventory, packaging, and marketing.

• Logistics: Managing inventory, shipping, and returns can be complex.

• Churn Rate: Retaining subscribers requires continuous innovation.

• Seasonality: Demand may fluctuate during holidays or slower months.

Requirements to Get Started

1. Niche Research: Identify your audience and theme.

2. Suppliers: Build relationships with reliable vendors.

3. Website Platform: Shopify, Cratejoy, or WooCommerce.

4. Packaging Materials: Branded boxes, filler, and tape.

5. Shipping Solution: Partner with USPS, UPS, or ShipStation.

Suggested Products to Maximize Results

1. Product Photography Setup: Capture high-quality images for marketing.

2. Custom Packaging Supplies: Invest in branded boxes and inserts.

3. Inventory Management Software: Tools like TradeGecko for tracking stock.

4. Subscription Platform: Cratejoy or Shopify’s subscription tools.

5. Shipping Label Printer: Save time and costs with a thermal printer like Rollo.

Conclusion

Starting a mystery box subscription business is an exciting way to blend creativity with consistent revenue. By carefully curating themed boxes, building a loyal subscriber base, and scaling effectively, you can turn this side hustle into a thriving business. With potential earnings of $4,000–$60,000 or more per month, the sky’s the limit for this business model. Start planning today and surprise your customers with unforgettable mystery boxes!